I've had a couple days to think about my experience. If I were younger, I think I would have been humiliated by my NEC audition day. My overall experience was that of humbling awe (if there is such a thing). I remember last year that I thought the audition process went so well. I really felt good about the whole thing. As this past year has gone by, I've learned so much and progressed immensely as a musician. As I took my Ear Tests, I was profoundly hit by how much I don't know all of these sounds. I can do well with ET tests when I take my time, sing the intervals or even play a couple notes to get my bearings, but that really isn't a mark of good ears. I don't have that instant recognition of intervals (except for a couple). I have to think a moment to intellectualize the pitches. During the Ear Test a chord was played and I recognized the chord. I had a good feeling of how to play that chord on my instrument and I had a good feeling of what notes I could play over it, but I couldn't identify it and I didn't have the skills to solfege my way through it. This is a concept that I really haven't looked at very much. ... The idea of hearing things and then responding to them can be a very intuitive process. I have my moments with this, but I don't have a lot of experience with looking at the theoretical perspective of playing by ear. I don't always know (by ear) that I'm playing the 9 or #11 of the chord that I'm on. I'm not sure if I need to, but I recognized for the first time that this is something to think about.....
-----
The singing portion of my exam didn't go so hot (in my opinion). I did much better last year because I worked so hard on the piece. This year I was more casual and in some sense didn't know the song that well. The chromatic scale was fine.
----
During my audition, there wasn't much talking or questions. I just played my two pieces and they said thank you. There was an Ear Test where someone played a line on the piano and I had to sing it back and then play it back. I probably got 75-80% on that. I was particularly distressed at this situation because it's my strongpoint, but I didn't understand the melody that was being played. There is a lot about Jazz & Bebop that I haven't studied. I'm more of a tonal, straight through the changes kind of guy, and this led to me missing the context of this melody.
----
the final part of the audition was to sing phrases over some changes and then to play over some changes. I don't think I did to well on that. I could make it rhythmically interesting, but I don't' have the pitch or ear control to hit the notes that I want. This is really when it hit me to how much I have to learn, or how I have to change my studies. My musicianship relies so much on my instrument and my intellect of what chord, scale or key were on at the moment. My ear makes executive decision but about the appropriateness of each lick, but I really don't hear to much ahead of what I'm playing. I hear possibilities, but not concrete ideas. I think this is also because I'm a little green in the jazz style.
---
So, my feeling after the audition was that of being shaken-up a bit. I was surprised at how surprised I was. I really felt inadequate as a Master's candidate.
---
I do recognize that there is a lot of "negative" thinking here. I'm looking into what I don't do very well (and that always is going to be a lot of things), but these things are skills that I think I need to make my music. Back to what I wrote earlier, about me being "humiliated" if I were younger: the difference is that now, the experience is a learning mechanism. I've learned that in some sense the current path I'm going on, isn't' going to bring me to where I want to go and that I have to work with focus in a different area that will probably require a decent amount of time and sweat. In that respect I'm really grateful for the experience because it helped show me what I'm doing wrong. It held a true mirror to my playing. Hopefully, I'll be able to keep this spirit with me to guide me through my own musical journey (along with the help from some others).